• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Wild Sunshine and Lemonade

  • Blog
  • Recipes
  • Our Story
  • Shop

Chocolate Peanut Butter Dirt Cake

September 13, 2016 by wildsunshine Leave a Comment

My kids thrive on eggs a thousand different ways, they snack on dried anchovies (yeah, crazy, I know!), and don’t flinch when we say baked peaches are dessert in the summer.

BUT…

We take birthdays very seriously. There ain’t no way we are behaving ourselves when it comes to dessert! This past weekend my husband got another year closer to 40 and declared that he wanted dirt cake. Not just any dirt cake, mind you, he wanted chocolate peanut butter dirt cake. When I was growing up, I loved dirt cake. I requested it for at least a few birthdays, complete with the foil-lined flower pot and fake flowers on top. Boy was I excited to make this for him!

kids making dirt cake

kids making dirt cake

I set out searching Pinterest for a peanut butter chocolate version, but found NONE. Can you believe that? In the world of pinterest, what I wanted apparently didn’t exist. So I invented. I based this on an Original Dirt Cake recipe and made several changes, including real whipped cream instead of Cool Whip, and a 50/50 split between vanilla and chocolate pudding.

The morning of daddy’s birthday, I told the kids we were going to eat dirt and worms for dessert. They didn’t buy it… at first. Then they said they were ok trying some dirt and worms because, let’s face it, in a household where true sugar-filled sweets are rare these kiddos cannot wait to get their hands on some homemade goodies. Of course once they started helping me make the “dirt” and saw the “worms,” they laughed. And begged to try a gummy worm.

But the BEST part of making daddy’s dirt cake was watching him eat it. When the man pauses multiple times and says “dang, this is amazing!” you know it’s good. So I wanted to share.

 

 Chocolate Peanut Butter Dirt Cake: crushed cookies, cream, pudding, and PB cups make this a hit


CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER DIRT CAKE

To make your cooking experience easy, I’ve included a few links to items I use and love. Please note that I receive a small commission from sales of certain items, but the price is the same for you. 

INGREDIENTS Chocolate Peanut Butter Dirt Cake: crushed cookies, cream, pudding, and PB cups make this a hit
– 1 full package of oreos
– 1/3 cup butter, softened (I use Kerrygold grass fed butter, available at Costco if you consume it like we do!)
– 8 oz. cream cheese, softened
– 3/4 cup powdered sugar
– 1 package 3.4 oz. instant vanilla pudding
– 1 package 3.4 oz. instant chocolate pudding
– 3 cups of milk (I use whole)
– 8 oz. whipping cream
– 15 Reeses peanut butter cups minis unwrapped and quartered
– 1/2 cup natural peanut butter
– Gummy Worms (these are awesome if you’re looking for something dye-free)

 

1. Crush oreos in a food processor until they resemble dirt.
2. Beat together butter, cream cheese & powdered sugar.
3. In a separate bowl, whisk vanilla pudding mix & 1.5 cups milk.
4. In a small bowl, whip the cream until it forms peaks. Fold into the vanilla pudding mixture.
5. Fold together cream cheese & pudding mixtures together until smooth.
6. In your whipped cream bowl (for the sake of dirty dishes), whisk the chocolate pudding and 1.5 cups milk. Set for 5 minutes. Swirl your peanut butter into the chocolate pudding.
7. Layer! I am slightly obsessed with my triffle dish because you can see all the amazing layers (snag one here) but you could go fancy and line a flower pot with foil. Always start with about a third of your “dirt.” I then used 1/2 of the vanilla pudding mixture, a few gummy worms, another 1/3 of the dirt, all of the chocolate pudding, sprinkle Reeses cups, the remaining vanilla pudding mixture, and top with what dirt is left and a few worms. Phew!

GLUTEN-FREE OPTION: Substitute a GF oreo and you should be set!

ENJOY!

 

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

Filed Under: Recipes Tagged With: chocolate, dessert, dirt cake, paleo, peanut butter, recipe

Previous Post: « My crazy life with three littles
Next Post: Wrangling Chickens Down on the Farm »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Hey Y’all!

I'm Amanda, a mama of four wild things and a growing herd of animals. We just built a farmhouse on our 13 acres of countryside in North Carolina, and are on our way to transform worn out tobacco pasture into a diverse landscape of animals, veggies, orchards, and grapevines. Join me on the farming journey! Read More…

Recent Posts

  • Lemon Ice Cream for Summertime
  • Blueberry Cobbler with Honey Biscuit topping
  • Rustic Farmhouse Banana Bread
  • We’re Building a Farmhouse!
  • A Perpetual Mischief Maker Sleeps in our Room

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

wildsunshinefarmgirl

Sometimes an emergency grocery store egg pickup is Sometimes an emergency grocery store egg pickup is a beautiful reminder of why I love farm fresh eggs 😍 Not much is as satisfying as feeding my kids nutrient dense food that we raised! Totally doubling our flock size this year... and tripling the size of their run so we can contain the garden-eating beasties. #backyardchickens #homesteadinglife #wildsunshinefarm #nofilter
If you haven’t spent the last 36 hours watching If you haven’t spent the last 36 hours watching your children go mud sledding and doing 189 loads of laundry, you’re missing out. Our one inch of snow was gone by lunch yesterday, and yet... #letthembewild #farmkids #countrylife #sendmoredetergent #wildsunshinefarm #powerofplay
Pulling carrots from the garden in January is such Pulling carrots from the garden in January is such a gift! We are down to the last few, and they are so sweet! Over here we are big time garden planning, both with veg and flowers, and designing pathways and patios and arbors! We still don’t have a sidewalk, and the ground is a mud pit every time it rains. Any guess how many muddy dog footprints are currently on the floor? 😂😂😭 Sidewalk is at the top of the list. #wildsunshinefarm #wintergarden #homesteading #homesteadmama
Sometimes you don’t realize how much you miss ha Sometimes you don’t realize how much you miss having a dog in your life until you have one ❤️#puppylove #mochadoodle #farmdogintraining #wildsunshinefarm
If you haven’t had the pleasure of spending the If you haven’t had the pleasure of spending the past 10 months of quarantine with a toddler, allow me to present today’s mess. A half devoured bag of marshmallows along with a pan, several smashed blueberries (in the new cabinet), and some rogue pistachios. Pretty certain this three year old cannot survive without his daily dose of mischief 🤯 #soreadyformycovidvaccine #mamabecrazy #letmeout #wildsunshinefarm #farmlife #homesteadmama
After the hustle of Christmas and a month of relax After the hustle of Christmas and a month of relaxing (and if I’m honest, baking cookies and taking way too many baths to wash off 2020), the farm is awake. It’s awake and beckoning with her many projects that must be done before spring... which means I have to finish this beauty that I didn’t get around to last year. I’ve had the wood since June, and am finally building us a larger dining table. Hoping that 2021 brings the return of friends around this table and dinners with family! 

#farmhousetable #trestletable #wildsunshinefarm #winteronthefarm
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Social

  • View wildsunshineandlemonade’s profile on Facebook
  • View wildsunshine_amanda’s profile on Instagram
  • View wildsunshineAC’s profile on Pinterest

Copyright © 2021 · Foodie Pro Theme by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress